Coupons.com has added two new $1 NYC Eye Product printable coupons good on any product $1.72 or greater. Target has Eye Liner selling for $.97 each. You should be able to use this coupon on two Eye Liners in order to get them for 2/$.94. You could also see if there are any eye products for right around $1.99
*Note – check zip 11223 if you can’t find the coupon in your area. These are manufacturer’s coupons, so they can be used anywhere (not just CVS or Duane Reade).